The Power of Choice: Building Trust in the Jewelry Industry

Sept 2, 2026 | About Lab Grown

One of the great beauties of the jewelry industry is that it remains deeply rooted in independent businesses. Namely, local boutiques, family-owned stores, and custom jewelers, who have built their businesses around personal relationships and a genuine connection to their communities. These retailers share a common purpose: to help their customers celebrate life’s most meaningful moments with beautiful, thoughtfully chosen jewelry that is treasured for a lifetime.

Our role as the industry professionals, brands, retailers, and sales associates is to give consumers something truly valuable: the freedom to choose. At Chatham, we believe in options and in the power of an informed decision. It is a philosophy that has guided us for nearly 90 years.

Our responsibility is simple: educate, inform, guide, and advise. We should help consumers understand their choices, answer their questions honestly and without bias, and give them the confidence to choose what is right for them. That is what expertise and good customer service should look like.

We should also stand firmly against anything that compromises those principles, whether through confusion, misinformation, or deception. The FTC’s Jewelry Guides reflect this same concern. In its 2018 revision, the FTC removed “synthetic” from examples of appropriate terms for identifying lab-grown or lab-created diamonds, in part because consumer research found that many people associated "synthetic" with an imitation or fake.

Consumers should not be expected to be scientists. They should be able to rely on us to make the science understandable. Rather than overwhelming them with technical terminology, explain the meaningful differences between a mined gemstone or diamond and one that is lab-grown. Explain how each is formed, where it comes from, and the qualities they share. Give them honest talking points about the advantages and considerations of each.


At Chatham, we use a simple ice analogy to help explain the lab-grown gemstone process. Water placed in a controlled environment, such as a freezer, naturally crystallizes into ice. It is the same material as lake ice, but simply from a different source.


Growing gemstones works in much the same way. The appropriate starting material is placed in a carefully controlled environment that recreates the conditions needed for crystals to form. Over time, the material naturally crystallizes into a gemstone. This simple analogy helps illustrate an important distinction: lab-grown gemstones are not fake, artificial, or imitations, like the term "synthetic" implies. Actually, they are crystals formed through a controlled process.

Be your clients' trusted advisor, not simply their salesperson. Listen to what matters to them. Educate without judgment. Guide without pressure. Inspire them to find the piece that feels right for their story.

When we do that, we build something far more valuable than a single sale; we build trust, loyalty, and relationships that can last a lifetime.

And, perhaps, that is something worth remembering as an industry.

We should celebrate our differences as much as our similarities. Mined and lab-grown gemstones each have a place in our industry, and consumers deserve the opportunity to understand and choose between them.

Rather than dividing our efforts or trying to control the conversation, we should be willing to work together to bring people back into jewelry stores and rediscover the experience of seeing, touching, trying on, and falling in love with a beautiful piece of jewelry.

After all, the jewelry industry was built on independent businesses, personal relationships, craftsmanship, and the meaningful moments that connect people to jewelry. If we come together around those shared values, we can preserve those roots while creating a stronger, more welcoming future for the entire industry.